Elsie's Peanut Butter Cookies



Our classic peanut butter cookie is timeless! Made with creamy peanut butter, brown sugar and a hint of vanilla... you won't be able to eat just one!

Baked Good Love - Shelf Life

Immediate Happiness

  • Most of our baked goods can manage a few days wrapped in plastic wrap or an airtight container, although they're so tasty you'll want to enjoy right away!

Long Term Happiness

  • All of our baked goods freeze well. They can be double wrapped to help provide you with a special treat in the future. It is best to let any frozen baked goods thaw at room temperature in their wrapping before you serve. 

Shipping is INCLUDED to East Coast destinations and will arrive in 1-2 days after shipping. 

For all other locations we use Expedited Shipping so your cookies arrive fresh and delicious within 2 days. For Mid-West locations the fee for Expedited Shipping is $10.00. For locations along with Pacific Coast the fee for Expedited Shipping is $15.00. We only ship baked goods Monday-Wednesday to ensure freshness. 

INGREDIENTS: Soybean Oil, Eggs, Vanilla, Peanut Butter, Brown Sugar, Sugar, Baking Soda, Baking Powder, Salt, Flour

We recommend that guests with nut allergies of any type do not consume our Bake Shop products. We do not have the ability to make our nut products completely separate from the rest of our baked goods. The same ingredients, equipment, etc. is used for all of the Bake Shop products. We feel it's better to err on the side of caution.

Customer Reviews

Based on 4 reviews

I've been ordering cookies for several years and I love these cookies and my love theme too.

My Favorite Cookies!!

I don't have a sweet tooth but when I crave a cookie it has to be Elsie's Peanut Butter Cookies. These are not too sweet and have a perfect balance of sweet and Peanut Butter flavor! Nive and crunchy every time. This year since we were not able to make our yearly trip to PA I ordered them online and shipping was fast and the packaging was very nice and secure.

Best PB Cookies!

I've got high standards where pb cookies are concerned. I have ended my search for the best-tasting pb cookie. Moist, crunchy outside with moist inside - true pb flavor. Packaged well - not one arrived broken. Yes!!! Ordering these again.


These Peanut Butter Cookies are the best I've ever eaten, including my own. I can no longer bake anything as I am on Disability. Thank you for making such a wonderful cookie.