Baked Goods

From freshly baked cookies to the best shoo-fly pie in the land, you'll want to order a few extra of our baked goods to enjoy or share with a friend. Maybe give our whoopie pies a try – fluffy icing nestled between two cake-like halves in chocolate, pumpkin, or peanut butter – a delight for kids of all ages! For a true Lancaster County experience you won't want to miss our shoo-fly pies. We eat them warmed up with a little vanilla ice cream, sometimes even for breakfast! Our fruit breads are the perfect morning treat with a cup of coffee or tea! Can't enjoy your goodies right away, or want to save some for later? Simply place them in the freezer and pull out to thaw when you're ready in indulge!

 A Note About Shipping:

Our Baked Goods SHIP FREE to all East Coast destinations! To keep them fresh and delicious we use Expedited Shipping so your Baked Goods arrive in 1-2 days once shipped. For our friends who live further away from our bakery you'll see a shipping charge for the Expedited Shipping at checkout. For Mid-West locations Expedited Shipping is $10 and for Pacific Coast destinations Expedited Shipping is $15. Regardless of the destination your Baked Goods may be shipped separately and arrive before the rest of your order.