1-800-717-6198
Log in
Cart (
0
)
Checkout
Canning Kitchen
Jams, Jellies, & Preserves
Butters
Relishes
Pickled Beets
Salsas
Pickles
Mustard
Marinara Sauces
Dressings, Syrups, & Grilling Sauces
View all Canning Kitchen
Olive Oils & Balsamics
Extra Virgin Olive Oils
Flavored Olive Oils
White Balsamics
Dark Balsamics
Olive Specialty & Pasta
Olive Oil Accessories
View all Oils & Balsamics
Spices & Seasonings
Gourmet Seasonings
Spice Blends
Bread Dip Blends
Salts & Peppers
Sugars & Sweet Blends
Salt-Free Seasonings
Seasoning Samplers
Exclusive Seasoning Collections
View all Spices & Seasonings
Baked Goods
Cookies
Pies
Whoopie Pies
Fruit Breads
All Baked Goods
Coffee & Tea
Coffees
K-Cups
Loose Leaf Teas
Tea Bags
View all Coffee & Tea
Gifts
Gift Boxes
Gift Trays & Baskets
Gifts Under $30
Gifts $30 to $50
Gifts $50 & Up
Bundles
Gifts For Her
Gifts for Him
Online Gift Cards
Village Gift Certificates
View all Gifts
Mixes & Dips
Baking Mixes
Cheesecake & Dip Mixes
Soup Mixes
Drink & Cocktail Mixes
One-Pot Meals
View all Mixes & Dips
Meat & Cheese
Artisan Cheese
Cured Meats
Meat Sticks & Jerky
Meat & Cheese Accessories
View all Meat & Cheese
Gourmet Foods
Rubs, Burger Mixes & Grinders
Crackers, Pretzels & Snacks
Applesauce & Sweet Spreads
Savory Sauces, Spreads & Aiolis
Hot Sauces
Honey & Syrups
Fudge
Popcorn
Candy
Other
View all Gourmet Foods
Bath & Body
Handcrafted Bar Soap
Foaming Hand Soap
Candy Scrubs
Shampoo & Conditioner Hair Bars
Bath Bombs & Shower Bursts
Planted-Based Laundry Soap
Goat's Milk Soap & Lotion
Aromatic Bath Salts
View all Bath & Body
For Your Home
Event Favors
New
Peanut Butter Collection
Home
Peanut Butter Collection
Page 1 of 1
Sort by:
Featured
Best Selling
Alphabetically: A-Z
Alphabetically: Z-A
Price: Low to High
Price: High to Low
Date: New to Old
Date: Old to New
Calling all Peanut Butter Lovers -- We've surely got something to satisfy your sweet tooth! Cookies, Whoopie Pies and our irresistible & world famous Peanut Butter Schmier are just a few of the sweet & savory peanut butter favorites around here.
Peanut Butter Schmier
20 reviews
from
$5.49
Elsie's Peanut Butter Cookies
13 reviews
$12.99
Chocolate Whoopie Pies - Peanut Butter Filling (Half-Dozen)
5 reviews
$16.99
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookies
7 reviews
$12.99
Caramel Sea Salt Peanut Butter Cup
No reviews
$6.99
Bacon Peanut Butter Cup
No reviews
$6.99
Traditional Peanut Butter Cup
1 review
$6.99
Butters Gift Box
3 reviews
$31.99
Butter Collection Gift Box
No reviews
$34.99
Savory Snack Box
2 reviews
$22.99
Sweet Snack Box
No reviews
Sold Out
Search