$12.49
Description Mix & Match any 12+ Jars in our Canning Kitchen, Save 10% Our guests always...
$15.99
Description Our classic peanut butter cookie is timeless! Made with creamy peanut butter, brown sugar...
$19.99
Description Lancaster County's favorite sweet treat! Our soft cake-like chocolate cookies stuffed with rich peanut...
$15.99
Description Our rich chocolate cookies are stuffed with mini peanut butter chips. You get the...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Our delicious fudge recipe combined with silky smooth peanut butter make this fudge every...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription The best of both worlds, our premium chocolate fudge combined with top of the...
$7.99
Treat yourself to a giant peanut butter cup with sweet caramel, covered in rich dark...
$7.99
Treat yourself to a giant peanut butter cup with real bacon, covered in milk chocolate! The...
$7.99
Go head, you deserve it! Treat yourself to a giant peanut butter cup covered in...
$32.99
Choosing my favorite butter from our four delicious flavors is like trying to choose my...
$35.99
Apple Butter may be the most widely known, but Lancaster County has become home to...
$22.99
– Sold OutWhen it comes to snacking, there are two options: Savory or Sweet. This box is...
$6.99
Description Friends of ours insisted we make it. So we did. And then we tried...
$6.99
Description Yes, chocolate, and peanut butter...and chocolate! A tried and true combination, chocolate peanut butter...
$6.99
– Sold OutDescription A sweet-hot Peanut Butter. Made with our low-sugar Honey Roasted mixture and St. Lucifer's...
$9.99
Description Our Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread is made with roasted peanuts, marshmallow and cream, for...
