$19.99
Description Lancaster County's favorite sweet treat! Our chocolate whoopie pies are the classic chocolate and...
$19.99
Description Lancaster County's favorite sweet treat! Our soft cake-like chocolate cookies stuffed with rich peanut...
$19.99
Description Lancaster County's favorite sweet treat! Our pumpkin whoopie pies are made with a soft, cake-like cookie...
$19.99
Description Lancaster County's favorite sweet treat! Our whoopie pies are soft cake-like cookies stuffed with...
$15.99
Description We have perfected this all-American classic to pack just the right amount of chocolate...
$15.99
Description Our Cranberry Oatmeal cookies have quickly become a favorite around here! We took our...
$15.99
Description The cookie that started it all over 60 years ago! Our founder, Pat Burnley,...
$15.99
Description A Lancaster County favorite! Our Snickerdoodles are crispy sugar cookies sprinkled with a delicious...
$15.99
Description Our classic peanut butter cookie is timeless! Made with creamy peanut butter, brown sugar...
$15.99
Description Is it a brownie or a cookie? With this much chocolate packed into every...
$15.99
Description Chewy and delicious oatmeal cookies stuffed with plump raisins! Mmmm... an oldie but a...
$15.99
Description Plump, sweet dates are the "WOW" ingredient in this old fashioned cookie favorite! Made...
$15.99
Description Our rich chocolate cookies are stuffed with mini peanut butter chips. You get the...
$15.99
Description Our Village Mascot, Yummie, is pretty popular around here - he even has his...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% New York Style Cheesecake, perfect for that quick...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% Visions of a tropical paradise topped off with...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% Plump blueberries and tangy lemon combine to make...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% We have also included delicious recipes for healthy...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% Chocolate lovers unite with this rich and velvety...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% Enjoy the sweet cinnamon flavor of your...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% Real pumpkin, cinnamon and nutmeg make this delicious,...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% This cheesecake mix has a mild summer strawberry...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% Tart Lemon and Sweet Raspberry flavors combine in...
$11.99
Description Our Lemon Curd is made from an old family recipe using all the ingredients...
$11.99
Description Our delicious Raspberry Curd is made from an old family recipe using all the...
$11.99
Description Our delicious Key Lime Curd is made from an old family recipe using all...
$10.99
Description Our Lemon Curd is made from an old family recipe using all the ingredients...
$7.99
Description This item really puts the FUN in funnel cakes. Bring the carnival to your...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Choose your favorite 4 flavors, and receive a slice of each in this create-your-own...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Our best seller! This creamy, velvety smooth chocolate will melt in your mouth and...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Our delicious fudge recipe combined with silky smooth peanut butter make this fudge every...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription The best of both worlds, our premium chocolate fudge combined with top of the...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription What is better than our regular chocolate, well for dark chocolate lovers, the answer...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Take our chocolate fudge, add delicious pecans and then finish it off with pieces...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Nothing is more distinctive than the aroma of fresh maple and this fudge will...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Combine our classic smooth and silky vanilla fudge with a crunchy chocolate cookie and...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Our same premium chocolate fudge with a generous amount of walnuts throughout. Each box will...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Just like your favorite ice cream; we blend our chocolate fudge with pecans and...
$19.99
– Sold OutDescription Delicious and nutty is the best way to describe this fudge. Our sweet and...
$8.99
Description Blueberry Muffins! Use this delicious mix to make 18 muffins. Why stop at Blueberry?...
$9.99
Description Our Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread is made with roasted peanuts, marshmallow and cream, for...
$15.99
Description When you can't decide which cookie variety to choose, our box of a dozen...
$6.99
– Sold OutDescription A sweet-hot Peanut Butter. Made with our low-sugar Honey Roasted mixture and St. Lucifer's...
$6.99
Description Yes, chocolate, and peanut butter...and chocolate! A tried and true combination, chocolate peanut butter...
$6.99
Description Friends of ours insisted we make it. So we did. And then we tried...
$5.99
Description Just add this delicious mix of oats, brown sugar, King Arthur Flour and spices...
$62.99
Description Spread joy and share smiles with our Delightful Desserts Box! Inside, you'll find twelve...
$4.99
Description Mix & Match any 3 Dip or Cheesecake Mixes, Save 15% We have also included delicious recipes for healthy...
